TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai taste-tested 12 frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week, looking for a substitute for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. She chose Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese, citing similar ingredients and taste and a lower per-sandwich price; the finding reflects one reviewer’s comparison, not a controlled or broad consumer study.
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese her preferred frozen alternative to McDonald’s Egg McMuffin after eating 12 sandwiches from five brands over a week. Her comparison found the frozen option cheaper per sandwich based on the prices she paid, though it is a single reviewer’s taste test rather than a broad consumer survey.
Domrongchai said the Jimmy Dean sandwich was the closest match among the products she tried because both it and the Egg McMuffin combine an English muffin, egg, sausage and cheese. She described the frozen sandwich’s sausage as juicy, its egg as soft after reheating, and its cheese as gooey and sharp. She also found it less greasy than the McDonald’s sandwich, while saying it retained flavor.
The price comparison in the article was $4.89 for the McDonald’s sandwich and $8 for a four-pack of Jimmy Dean sandwiches. That works out to $2 per frozen sandwich using the package price Domrongchai reported, compared with the restaurant price she paid. McDonald’s breakfast with a hash brown and coffee cost her $7.29. These are the prices in the report, not a guarantee of current prices at other locations or retailers.
The products are similar but not identical. Domrongchai noted that the Jimmy Dean sausage includes chicken, and that its egg is a scrambled disk; the McDonald’s sandwich uses a whole egg with a firm yolk. Her test included products from five brands, including Trader Joe’s, but the source does not list all 12 sandwiches or provide a scoring system. The selection is therefore best read as a personal recommendation based on her week of tasting.
A Lower-Cost Freezer Option
The comparison speaks to a practical choice for people who want a quick breakfast sandwich without making a restaurant trip. At the prices Domrongchai reported, the four-pack cost less per sandwich than the Egg McMuffin she bought, while offering a familiar combination of muffin, sausage, egg and cheese. Keeping a package at home could also make the option more convenient for some readers.
The result does not establish that frozen sandwiches are always less expensive or preferable. Grocery and restaurant prices vary, and the review did not compare nutrition, ingredient quality, preparation time or value across every product in a systematic way. Its usefulness is narrower: it identifies one frozen sandwich that one food editor considered a close taste and texture match for a specific fast-food item.
Jimmy Dean English Muffin Egg and Cheese frozen breakfast sandwich
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sandwiches Were Compared
Domrongchai’s report began with her preference for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin and her concern about paying $4 to $5 for one, as stated in the article. She set out to find a frozen substitute and ate a dozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands during one week. The source describes this as a taste test and gives her impressions of the leading pick, rather than a formal blind test with multiple tasters.
The article also refers to an earlier Kitchn comparison by contributor Kate, who had selected a Jimmy Dean sausage, egg and cheese biscuit as a lower-cost match for a McDonald’s biscuit. That earlier result is separate from Domrongchai’s test: this report focused on finding an alternative to the Egg McMuffin, and selected the English muffin version.
““The sausage is juicy, the eggs are surprisingly soft even though they were formerly frozen, and the cheese is gooey and sharp.””
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn food editor
Limits of the Taste Test
The report does not say whether the sandwiches were tasted blind, whether other people took part, or how the products were scored. It also does not give a complete list of all 12 sandwiches, package sizes for every brand, or a detailed nutrition comparison. The prices reflect what Domrongchai paid when she wrote the article; current prices and availability may differ.
It is also not clear how the frozen sandwiches would compare for readers with different preferences, such as those who favor a whole egg, a particular sausage seasoning, or a less processed breakfast. The recommendation is the reviewer’s judgment, not a finding that Jimmy Dean is objectively better than McDonald’s or every other frozen option.
Check Prices Before Buying
The Kitchn’s article invites readers to share their experiences with the Jimmy Dean sandwich, but the source material does not announce further testing or a planned follow-up. Readers considering the comparison can check local grocery and restaurant prices, since the review’s price gap depends on the specific prices reported. The outlet’s product disclosure also says it independently selects products and may earn a commission when readers buy through its links.
Key Questions
Which frozen breakfast sandwich did The Kitchn recommend?
Ali Domrongchai selected Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese as her closest frozen match to a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin among the sandwiches she tried.
How many sandwiches were included in the test?
Domrongchai said she ate 12 breakfast sandwiches from five brands over the course of a week. The source does not name every product she tested.
How did the reported prices compare?
She paid $4.89 for a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin and reported paying $8 for four Jimmy Dean sandwiches, or $2 per sandwich based on that package price. Prices can vary by store and date.
Are the Jimmy Dean and McDonald’s sandwiches identical?
No. Both have an English muffin, egg, sausage and cheese, but Domrongchai said the Jimmy Dean sausage includes chicken and its egg is a scrambled disk; the McDonald’s sandwich has a whole egg with a firm yolk.
Source: rss
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
