TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A Good Housekeeping guide featuring pumpkin-carving professional Michael Natiello lays out steps for cleaner designs and a pumpkin that may stay fresh longer. Its tips include selecting an unbruised pumpkin with a sturdy stem, cutting an opening at the bottom, thinning the carving area and sealing cut edges with petroleum jelly. The guidance is practical advice, not a guarantee of how long a pumpkin will last.
Good Housekeeping has published a pumpkin-carving guide featuring advice from Michael Natiello, a pumpkin-carving professional and creative director of The Great Jack-o’-Lantern Blaze, on making jack-o’-lanterns easier to carve and helping them stay fresh. The recommendations focus on choosing a sound pumpkin, preparing its interior carefully and sealing cut edges, though the guide does not promise a specific number of extra days.
The guide recommends starting with a fresh pumpkin that has a sturdy stem, no bruises and a flat base. A stable pumpkin is less likely to roll during carving, while damaged or older fruit may be a poor starting point for a display meant to last. Good Housekeeping advises taking time with each step rather than rushing from selection to cutting.
For the opening, Natiello recommends cutting from the bottom, which the guide says can help prevent the pumpkin’s sides from caving in. If carving a top opening instead, cut the lid at an angle so it is less likely to fall inside. Scoop out the pulp and seeds, then thin the wall behind the planned design to about 1¼ inches, making the shell easier to cut through.
For more controlled designs, the article suggests sketching a pattern on paper, taping it to the pumpkin and marking the lines with small holes. Natiello recommends a serrated kitchen knife or an X-Acto knife and advises making straight up-and-down cuts, not slanted ones. Begin with larger rough cuts and tidy the edges afterward. The guide also suggests applying petroleum jelly to cut edges to limit moisture loss; if the pumpkin shrivels, it says a face-down soak in cold water for up to eight hours may help revive it.
Small Steps That Shape the Result
The advice addresses two familiar problems for Halloween displays: designs that are hard to execute and pumpkins that begin to sag before the holiday. Choosing a stable pumpkin and transferring a pattern can make the work more manageable, while thinning the carving area and cutting in straight strokes may help produce cleaner features.
For people displaying a carved pumpkin outdoors, the preservation suggestions offer low-effort measures to try after carving. But the article gives no controlled comparison of how long treated pumpkins last versus untreated ones, and conditions such as temperature and exposure may affect results. Readers should treat the methods as practical guidance rather than a shelf-life guarantee.
Products Worth Considering

Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 12-Piece Stainless Steel Cookware Set

Cuisinart Chef's Classic 11-Piece Stainless Steel Cookware Set

Ninja Foodi Smart 6-in-1 Indoor Grill and Air Fryer, 4 Qt, FG551
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Pumpkin Choice to Display
The source is a Good Housekeeping service article about a seasonal Halloween activity, not a report of a new product, scientific study or official safety standard. It presents a sequence of steps, from choosing a pumpkin through carving and display, and attributes several recommendations to Natiello.
Its display tips include using battery-operated votives or lights instead of an open flame. For a candle, the article says to place it inside before lighting and describes making a small vent hole where the lid blackens after the candle has burned briefly. It also suggests sprinkling cinnamon inside the lid for scent. These are optional finishing ideas, separate from the guide’s main carving and preservation advice.
How Long the Tips Can Help
The guide does not state how many days petroleum jelly might add to a pumpkin’s display life, or specify how often it should be reapplied. It also does not compare the advice with other preservation methods or report test results. The suggested cold-water soak is described as a way to revive a shriveled pumpkin, but the article does not say how long that effect lasts.
Results may vary with a pumpkin’s condition and where it is displayed. The source does not provide a detailed storage schedule, temperature range or food-safety assessment. Its recommendations should not be read as a guarantee that a carved pumpkin will remain in good condition through a particular date.
Before the Halloween Display
Readers planning to carve can follow the guide’s sequence: choose a firm, stable pumpkin; prepare a paper pattern; remove the pulp; and make measured cuts. Once finished, they can try sealing the edges and use a battery-operated light or another suitable display option. No follow-up testing or new milestone is announced in the source; the advice is a seasonal how-to guide rather than an ongoing development.
Key Questions
What kind of pumpkin should I choose for carving?
Good Housekeeping recommends a fresh pumpkin with a sturdy stem, no bruises and a flat bottom so it stays stable while you work.
Is it better to cut the opening at the top or bottom?
The guide attributes to Michael Natiello a recommendation to cut from the bottom, which may help keep the sides from caving in. If you make a top opening, cut the lid at an angle so it is less likely to drop inside.
How thick should the pumpkin wall be behind the design?
The guide recommends thinning the face area to about 1¼ inches so the shell is easier to pierce. It does not specify a thickness for every part of the pumpkin.
What can I do if my carved pumpkin starts to shrivel?
The article says to try a face-down soak in cold water for up to eight hours. It also recommends petroleum jelly on cut edges to help limit moisture loss, but neither method comes with a promised duration of results.
How can I light a jack-o’-lantern?
The guide suggests candles, Christmas lights or battery-operated votives. Battery-powered lighting avoids an open flame; if using a candle, follow the product’s safety directions and keep the pumpkin away from flammable materials.
Source: rss
